Maggie ([info]magnetic_pole) wrote,

Ficlet: Coward

Title: Coward
Characters: Minerva, Severus, Remus, Dumbledore, Eileen
Word count and rating: 850 words, G
Notes: For [personal profile] bethbethbeth, a belated birthday ficlet. Various lines taken from the Book-That-Must-Not-Be-Named.



“Coward!” Minerva yelled. She was furious that he had dared attack her. “Coward!”

But he was gone. Out of sight already, a broken window the only evidence of his treachery and departure.

No, the suit of armor outside would corroborate her story. Filius and Pomona had seen his wand raised against her.

Double agent, her arse. She had always known it would end like this.

Minerva shook with rage.

*

The appointment was so unlikely that she had immediately climbed the stairs to the headmaster’s office upon hearing it.

“The Carrows?” Minerva demanded, voice low.

“Indeed,” Severus said slowly, staring at her until she itched to look away. Loyal or disloyal, Eileen Prince’s son had always had an unhealthy love of power over others. Minerva rarely gave him the pleasure of experiencing it.

“There is bold, and then there is foolhardy,” she hissed. “You put us at risk.”

Severus raised an eyebrow. “You assume there is an ‘us,’” he said.

Minerva stared at him. “I wager my life on ‘us,’ young Severus,” she said. “When will you understand that?”

*

“Don’t move!” Minerva commanded, wand drawn.

The shadow at the end of the corridor raised both hands in surrender. “It’s me,” the shadow said, sounding exhausted. “Remus. Black seems to have escaped.”

Minerva’s sigh seemed to fill the castle.

“How convenient.” It was Severus now, at her shoulder, wand still raised. “Minerva, keep your wand trained on Lupin. I’ll return in a moment.”

Only after Severus’ footsteps had faded into the corridor did Remus speak again.

“I give him the opportunity to poison me every month,” Remus said. “Listening to him, you might think it was the other way around.”

“Hands in the air, Lupin,” Minerva replied, imitating Severus’ drawl. “And keep that humor where it belongs.”

*

The Headmaster had been opposed, at first. “He is too young,” he said slowly. “Hardly older than the students. He will abuse the opportunity.”

“Better here than elsewhere,” Minerva countered. Privately, she concurred, but Eileen had stood fast. Convince him, she had said. Whatever it takes. “You taught him as a boy, Albus. You know him.”

Dumbledore templed his hands and closed his eyes.

“He looks up to you,” Minerva said, crossing her fingers under the table. Eileen had showed her the memories of Severus’ last stay at home. His fear was palpable. “He needs guidance.”

Dumbledore looked up at her, eyes bright and concerned. “I will arrange the interview.”

If only it were that easy.

*

There was no owl the bright summer morning Eileen and Severus arrived in the garden of Minerva’s Hogsmeade cottage. Just the tell-tale double pop of Side-Along Apparition and a squawk and the sound of four trunks and a cage squashing her tomatoes.

“Minerva!” Eileen called. “Are you awake?” Minerva held the heavy wooden door open for them. She hugged Eileen as she passed, silencing her apologies before they began. Severus brushed by them both.

Minerva had already made breakfast and put sheets on the extra beds, but Severus still glowered at her.

*

Eileen Prince was married in a stylish, white Muggle dress that skimmed the tops of her knees. She had small bouquet of primroses and a lavender hat pinned on her dark hair at a jaunty angle.

She was also as sick as a Krup. Minerva held her hat as she leaned over the toilet.

Either nerves or morning sickness. Neither boded well.

“Tell me it will be fine, Minnie,” Eileen said softly. “Please.”

“It will be fine,” Minerva said. She passed Eileen some tissue, and Eileen wiped her mouth.

“How do you know?” Eileen whispered.

“Love,” Minerva said simply.

Eileen blanched. “I don’t even--”

“I”m not talking about Tobias,” Minerva said.

*

The day Severus Snape flew out the window was the day Minerva McGonagall almost lost her faith. When she realized he was gone, she closed her eyes and let out a long, shuddering sigh.

When she opened them again, Filius and Pomona were staring at her, and Harry and Luna had joined them by the broken window.

“He jumped,” she said shortly, forestalling their questions.

“You mean he’s dead?” Harry asked. He was not; they could all see his dark form flapping against the evening sky, incongruous and ridiculous.

Coward!

Horace arrived, a sure sign a crowd was forming. “Harry? My dear boy, what a surprise....Minerva, do explain...Severus...what?”

Minerva pulled back her shoulders and tried to remember where she kept her faith. It was stored somewhere near humor, she was certain. “Our headmaster,” she said dryly. “Has taken a short break.”

That made it sound as if he were sitting by the sea with a drink, Minerva thought. The very idea of Severus sitting by the sea made her want to laugh. But perhaps he was. Perhaps he'd given up the whole thing as a bad job. Perhaps he was back in her cottage in Hogsmeade talking with his mother. Or perhaps he was sitting out on school grounds somewhere, searching for the courage of his convictions.

Now was the time to do so, if there ever was.

Be brave for us, Severus, Minerva thought. Be brave.

This entry was originally posted at http://magnetic-pole.dreamwidth.org/15384.html. It has comment count unavailablecomments.
Tags: char: eileen prince, char: minerva mcgonagall, char: severus snape, fandom: harry potter

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Your reply will be screened

  • 14 comments

[info]secretsolitaire

October 23 2010, 04:11:36 UTC 1 year ago

This is fantastic. I love the little moments of wry humor.

[info]magnetic_pole

October 24 2010, 19:22:11 UTC 1 year ago

Thanks so much, S! M.

[info]perverse_idyll

October 23 2010, 04:23:51 UTC 1 year ago

Owwww. Those last lines sting. And they stop too soon! I long to know Minerva's reaction to what Harry reveals of Snape's fate. It's almost physically painful not to overhear her thoughts, once the truth is so starkly announced.

I particularly like the sequence in which Severus tries to stare Minerva down, and she reflects that she rarely gives him the pleasure. And the way she stands steadfast in believing there's an 'us.' So spare and yet it speaks volumes.

Btw, I've never told you how much I love your Snape ficlets. Someday I intend to go back and comment on each of them as they deserve, but for now I just wanted to say they strike repeatedly to the heart, and even more tellingly to the origins, of his character. They never fail to leave an indelible impression.

[info]magnetic_pole

October 24 2010, 19:21:54 UTC 1 year ago

Thanks for saying that, PI. I've written quite a few (for me, that is! not being very prolific) short, fragmentary stories about Snape that seem to reflect the fact I haven't quite gotten him figured out. He eludes me.

I think one of the most interesting things about him is that JKR's ending for him (revealing "good" motives) doesn't do much for me in terms of clearing up the murky morality of his actions. In the end, was he so far in that it didn't matter what side he was on? I'm not so sure that Minerva would fully forgive him, even knowing what Harry knows.

But in any case, thank you for reading, and thanks for your kind words! M.

[info]perverse_idyll

October 24 2010, 20:17:46 UTC 1 year ago

Oh, I fully agree that the 'reveal' in DH is immensely unsatisfying as a reason for Snape's behavior; even his love is portrayed as flawed and repellent. It doesn't actually account for any moral growth on his part, which I think is visible in The Prince's Tale. Moral growth doesn't equal a personality transplant, and I think that confuses a lot of readers.

But it also leaves fan writers a lot of room to speculate about Snape's (to me) intrinsic darkness. That murkiness and his obvious affinity for the grimmer, more primitive* side of magic isn't really something the series has time for, since it's Harry's story. Snape's complexity necessarily occurs on the sidelines.

I've always seen Snape as someone to whom Darkness comes naturally, but there are hints that his decision to work for 'the Light' (there's no equivalent canon term for magic that's not Dark) shifts from a compulsion placed on him by Dumbledore and his own remorse and becomes, as he matures, a conscious choice. That doesn't make him less Dark as a wizard or less comfortable and capable of things that would disturb Minerva terribly. Even a 'redeemed' Snape would be morally ambiguous to the bone.

I wish there was more Eileen fic. I wish there was more Snape family fic in general. (Btw, did you ever read [info]vissy's Severus/Eileen entry for [info]hp_beholder, Playing for Keeps? It's just stunning, and it speaks painfully to why Severus turned out the way he did.

Also, while I'm being parenthetical, in the same [info]crack_van month during which I recced [info]vissy's fic, I also recced you. Which I thought you might like to know in case you hadn't seen it.)

*primitive as in mythical, deeper, amoral, a connection to forces that can be used constructively or destructively, so ancient they threaten to overpower anyone trying to command them. This is entirely my interpretation, of course.

[info]kellychambliss

October 23 2010, 04:37:47 UTC 1 year ago

Very well-done indeed -- perceptive and understated and deeply sad/steadfast. I love the "us" and "it was stored somewhere near humor" and the tantalizing hints of backstory with Eileen and boy Severus.

Little thing -- I think you're missing a "was" in the opening line

[info]magnetic_pole

October 24 2010, 19:16:54 UTC 1 year ago

As I said to tarte below, the only thing that might be more fascinating than Snape is Snape's mother. What a story there must be there! Thanks for reading, K, as always! And thanks for catching the missing word. M.

[info]bethbethbeth

October 23 2010, 05:57:54 UTC 1 year ago

Oh, hon...this is excellent! Minerva knows Severus so well...and yet despite the fact that she's known him since before he was born (Eileen!), even she is never quite certain about him, is she?

And then there's that word: "coward." He just can't fight against it, not when Minerva's involved, and so he has to fly away (looking 'incongruous and ridiculous' as he flies). Be brave indeed, Severus.

What a wonderful gift. Thank you!!

[info]magnetic_pole

October 24 2010, 19:12:17 UTC 1 year ago

It's the dilemma of their relationship, isn't it (however you imagine that relationship)--Minerva just wants to be sure of him, and he's never going to be that person. Thanks for reading, beth, and best wishes for another wonderful, fannish year! M.

[info]tarteaucitron

October 23 2010, 09:23:30 UTC 1 year ago

lovely!

eileen prince is a backdrop character with a lot of potential, and i like how you flesh her out. the idea that minerva trusted snape for her sake is a great and intriguing one.

[info]magnetic_pole

October 24 2010, 19:10:55 UTC 1 year ago

Snape is an amazing character, but if it's possible, Snape's mother might be even more fascinating. (What had to happen in his childhood to create the adult Snape?) Thanks for reading, t. M.

[info]islandsmoke

October 23 2010, 14:20:29 UTC 1 year ago

Coward. What a hurtful, unfair word to use against him. What a sad, twisted, person Snape was, and yet he possessed some sterling qualities. So unfair to end his life the way Jo did.

Oh, yes! Loved this. :)

Be brave for us.

*sniff* Even if it did make me cry.

[info]magnetic_pole

October 24 2010, 19:09:13 UTC 1 year ago

He's such a mix, isn't he? I don't think JKR knew what a good thing she had going with him.

DH coming out in a few weeks is making me think about him again, and how unsatisfying his death was. *sigh* But thanks for reading! M.

[info]therealsnape

October 25 2010, 05:24:20 UTC 1 year ago

Brilliantly done.
I love the moments of dry wit (yes, Remus's too)and the great final section. Somewhere near humour indeed.
Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Facebook Twitter More login options
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…